Seeking a new vehicle without breaking the bank? Consumer Reports’ latest top picks highlight that exceptional reliability and safety don’t necessitate premium prices. Despite the average new car price in the U.S. hovering around $48,641 this January, marking a 1.3% year-over-year increase according to Kelley Blue Book, Consumer Reports champions several 2025 models that are both budget-friendly and high-performing. These top-rated vehicles start at an accessible MSRP of $21,590, proving you can secure a dependable and enjoyable car without overspending.
According to Alex Knizek, associate director of auto test development for Consumer Reports, “You don’t have to spend that much to get a car that’s going to be safe and reliable and enjoyable to own.” This sentiment underscores Consumer Reports’ commitment to helping consumers make informed choices based on rigorous testing and data-driven analysis.
Furthermore, the 2025 top picks list reflects a continuing trend towards hybrid vehicles. Hybrids dominate six out of the ten categories this year, including three plug-in hybrid models. Knizek notes that their superior reliability, fuel efficiency, quiet interiors, and quick acceleration contribute to their strong performance in Consumer Reports’ evaluations. While hybrids were once significantly pricier than their gasoline counterparts, the price difference has diminished, making them an increasingly attractive option for car buyers. “It tends to be a no-compromise solution,” Knizek explains, highlighting the balanced benefits of hybrid technology.
Consumer Reports’ annual rankings are the result of comprehensive testing of approximately 50 new vehicles each year. These vehicles are purchased anonymously from dealerships, ensuring unbiased evaluations. Following a 2,000-mile break-in period, each car undergoes over 50 tests. Reliability and owner satisfaction data gathered from Consumer Reports members further enhance the analysis, making these top picks a robust guide for consumers.
Consumer Reports’ Top Car Picks for 2025: Category Breakdown
Small Car: Nissan Sentra – Reliable and Feature-Rich
The Nissan Sentra earns its place as the top small car for its surprisingly spacious cabin and agile handling. Consumer Reports highlights its excellent fuel economy and an array of standard active safety features that often surpass those found in more expensive vehicles. The Sentra offers a compelling blend of practicality and value in the small car segment, making it a smart choice for budget-conscious buyers seeking reliability and essential features.
Subcompact SUV: Subaru Crosstrek – Adventure-Ready and Economical
For those seeking a versatile subcompact SUV, the Subaru Crosstrek stands out. Praised for its impressive fuel economy, generous ground clearance, and standard all-wheel drive, the Crosstrek is equally adept at navigating city streets and exploring off-road trails. Consumer Reports emphasizes the SUV’s user-friendly controls and comfortable seating in both the front and rear. While the base trim engine is adequate, upgrading to other trims unlocks a more energetic 182-hp, 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine, enhancing the driving experience.
Compact SUV: Subaru Forester – Practicality and Dependability Redefined
The redesigned 2025 Subaru Forester continues its reign as a top pick in the compact SUV category, marking its 12th consecutive year on Consumer Reports’ list. The latest model boasts a quieter cabin and increased cargo space compared to previous iterations, enhancing its practicality. Consumer Reports highlights the Forester’s excellent visibility, fuel efficiency, and standard all-wheel drive as key factors in its consistent top ranking. It remains a supremely sensible choice for families and individuals alike.
Midsized Car: Toyota Camry – Hybrid Efficiency and Smooth Performance
Completely redesigned for 2025, the Toyota Camry solidifies its position as a leading midsized car. Now exclusively offered as a hybrid, the Camry delivers a smooth and comfortable ride with responsive handling. Consumer Reports describes it as “comfortable, practical, and user-friendly,” emphasizing its well-rounded appeal. The hybrid powertrain enhances fuel economy without compromising performance, making it an exceptionally efficient and enjoyable sedan.
Small Pickup: Ford Maverick/Maverick Hybrid – Car-Like Handling with Truck Utility
The Ford Maverick and Maverick Hybrid earn accolades for their affordability, well-designed interior, and easy maneuverability in the small pickup segment. Consumer Reports points out the Maverick’s decent passenger space and car-like driving dynamics. While the standard 250-hp turbocharged four-cylinder engine is energetic, the 191-hp hybrid version truly shines, achieving an impressive 37 mpg in Consumer Reports’ tests. Knizek notes the Maverick’s unique appeal: “It drives kind of like a car, but then you have that bed on the back. It’s a unique vehicle on the marketplace.”
Fuel-Efficient SUV: Toyota RAV4 Prime (PHEV) – Powerful and Economical Plug-In Hybrid
The Toyota RAV4 Prime, the plug-in hybrid variant of the popular RAV4, is recognized as the top fuel-efficient SUV. Consumer Reports highlights its superior performance compared to other RAV4 models, citing a 0-to-60 mph acceleration in just over six seconds and an electric range of up to 42 miles. As a plug-in hybrid, the RAV4 Prime provides a “solid option” for those considering electrification without fully committing to a pure EV, according to Knizek.
Midsized SUV: Toyota Highlander Hybrid – Spacious, Efficient, and Family-Friendly
The Toyota Highlander Hybrid earns its place as the top midsized SUV for its excellent fuel economy, three-row seating, and standard all-wheel drive, achieving 35 mpg in Consumer Reports’ evaluations. Described as a “smart, versatile vehicle,” the Highlander Hybrid offers comfortable rear seats, a smooth ride, responsive handling, and a comprehensive suite of safety features, making it an ideal choice for families needing space and efficiency.
Electric Vehicle: Tesla Model Y – Practicality Meets Electric Performance
The Tesla Model Y leads the electric vehicle category, distinguished by its practical hatchback design. Consumer Reports praises its “otherworldly” acceleration and modern aesthetic, alongside its improved reliability. Knizek notes that the Model Y’s reliability is “above average compared to other electric vehicles,” indicating Tesla’s refined manufacturing process for this model. It’s a dependable and exciting EV option for consumers ready to embrace electric driving.
Luxury Compact SUV: Lexus NX350h/450h+ – Refined Comfort and Hybrid Choices
In the luxury compact SUV segment, the Lexus NX350h and NX450h+ stand out for their plush interiors and intuitive infotainment system. Consumer Reports highlights their “refined but firm” ride, coupled with responsive steering and capable handling. The NX350h hybrid achieved 38 mpg in testing, while the NX450h+ plug-in hybrid offers a 37-mile electric-only range and 35 mpg on gasoline, providing luxury buyers with efficient and sophisticated options.
Luxury Midsized SUV: BMW X5/X5 PHEV – Quiet Luxury and Powerful Performance
The BMW X5 and X5 PHEV top the luxury midsized SUV category, celebrated for their exceptionally quiet cabins and richly appointed interiors. Consumer Reports notes the base X5’s swift acceleration and 23 mpg, while the plug-in hybrid version offers a 39-mile electric range and 21 mpg once the battery depletes. With supportive seats and a refined driving experience, the BMW X5 models represent the pinnacle of luxury and performance in their class.
Conclusion: Smart Car Buying in 2025
Consumer Reports’ top picks for 2025 demonstrate that finding the Best New Cars involves prioritizing reliability, safety, and overall value, not just the highest price tag. With a strong showing from hybrid and plug-in hybrid vehicles, the automotive landscape is shifting towards efficiency without sacrificing performance or enjoyment. Whether you’re in the market for a compact car, a spacious SUV, or a luxurious ride, this list provides a data-backed starting point for making an informed and satisfying vehicle purchase in 2025.
