The luxury electric vehicle market is rapidly evolving, with discerning consumers seeking vehicles that offer both opulence and sustainability. As we move into 2024, two models stand out as leaders in this competitive segment: the BMW iX and the Porsche Taycan. Both cars represent the pinnacle of electric engineering, offering unique blends of luxury, performance, and cutting-edge technology. Let’s delve into what makes these two models some of the best luxury electric cars available this year.
BMW iX: Redefining Electric SUV Luxury
The BMW iX has been described as “a BMW like no other,” marking a significant departure and bold step into the all-electric future for the iconic German manufacturer. This luxury SUV flagship of BMW’s ‘i’ sub-brand is designed to provoke reaction and redefine expectations. While its exterior styling has been a point of debate, BMW has focused intensely on making the iX a landmark EV, symbolizing its transition towards electric mobility.
Pros:
- Exceptional Rolling Refinement: The iX excels in ride quality, offering a serene and exceptionally smooth experience on the road. Its ability to isolate passengers from road imperfections is truly remarkable.
- SUV-style Versatility and Space: As an SUV, the iX provides ample interior space and versatility, catering to families and those needing practicality without compromising on luxury.
- Inviting Luxury Interior: The cabin of the iX is a sanctuary of modern luxury, featuring high-quality materials, innovative design, and a welcoming atmosphere that sets a new standard for electric vehicle interiors.
Cons:
- Divisive Exterior Styling: The iX’s exterior design is polarizing and represents a significant departure from traditional BMW aesthetics, which may not appeal to all buyers.
- Regenerative Braking Effect Could Be Improved: While functional, the regenerative braking system in the iX could offer a more refined and intuitive feel.
- Expensive: As a flagship luxury electric SUV, the BMW iX comes with a premium price tag, placing it at the higher end of the market.
Roughly the size of the BMW X5, the iX utilizes a specialized platform constructed with lightweight composite materials and mixed metals, powered by dual electric motors, one on each axle. The entry-level iX xDrive40 starts just under £70,000, delivering 296bhp and a WLTP-certified range of 249 miles. Upgrading to the xDrive50, priced around £92,000, significantly boosts performance to 516bhp and extends the range to 373 miles, along with 200kW rapid charging capability. The iX M60 xDrive offers even greater power, but despite its lightweight platform design, all iX models weigh over 2.5 tonnes.
In comparison tests, the BMW iX outperformed the Mercedes-Benz EQS. While the EQS is comfortable, the iX distinguishes itself with superior ride isolation and sophistication, creating a uniquely compelling luxury experience. The BMW’s interior ambiance is also noted for being warmer and more idiosyncratic compared to the EQS’s futuristic and somewhat formal approach.
During road tests, the iX consistently impressed with its blend of generous SUV cabin space, genuinely relaxing and understated luxury, and world-class refinement. Its effortless performance and commendable real-world range are unmatched by other zero-emission SUVs in its class. Even if it doesn’t lead in outright range compared to some top-tier EVs, the BMW iX offers a compelling and complete package as a near-£100,000 luxury electric car, making it one of the best luxury electric cars of 2024.
Porsche Taycan: Electric Performance and Sophistication
Since its debut in 2020, the Porsche Taycan has expanded its range to include various configurations, from single and dual motor options to two- and four-wheel drive, offering a spectrum of power outputs and body styles including the saloon, Sport Turismo, and Cross Turismo. This broad selection has solidified the Taycan’s position from a pioneering sports EV to a strong contender in the luxury segment, even outselling every other Porsche model in the UK.
Pros:
- Outstanding Handling: The Taycan delivers exceptional handling, embodying Porsche’s renowned sports car DNA in an electric format. It offers precise control and dynamic responsiveness that is rare in the EV segment.
- Sophisticated Ride: Despite its sporty nature, the Taycan provides a remarkably sophisticated ride, balancing firmness with comfort, making it suitable for both spirited driving and everyday use.
- Electric Range Improved for 2024: Porsche has enhanced the Taycan’s electric range for the 2024 models, addressing a common concern and making it even more practical for longer journeys.
Cons:
- Ingress and Egress are a Bit Tight: The sleek, low-slung design of the Taycan means that getting in and out can be less graceful, particularly for rear passengers.
- Isn’t as Spacious as a Full-Size Saloon: While practical, the Taycan doesn’t offer the expansive interior space found in some full-size luxury saloons.
- Residual Values Aren’t What They Used to Be: Like many EVs, the Taycan’s residual values are subject to market fluctuations and technological advancements in the rapidly evolving EV landscape.
Regardless of configuration, the Taycan operates at a world-class level. Even the more versatile Cross Turismo models, with increased cargo space and a raised ride height, do not compromise on the Taycan’s dynamic capabilities. It boasts an incredibly absorptive yet controlled ride, combined with communicative steering, sharp handling responses, and immense real-world pace.
While its electric range isn’t class-leading, achieving 250 miles in mixed, real-world conditions is feasible for most Taycan versions. Accommodating up to five passengers and offering a boot comparable to a BMW 3 Series Touring, the Porsche Taycan is one of the most accomplished EVs available across various budgets. Entry prices for certain configurations with options start below £90,000, making it an accessible entry point into the realm of best luxury electric cars.
Conclusion
Both the BMW iX and Porsche Taycan represent the pinnacle of luxury electric vehicles in 2024. The BMW iX offers unmatched SUV versatility, interior luxury, and ride refinement, appealing to those seeking a spacious and comfortable electric experience. The Porsche Taycan, on the other hand, delivers thrilling performance and sophisticated handling synonymous with the Porsche brand, attracting drivers who prioritize driving dynamics in their luxury EV. Choosing between these two best luxury electric cars ultimately depends on individual preferences and priorities, but both models undoubtedly set new benchmarks in the luxury electric vehicle segment for 2024.
